hidden half of domestic violence
to have eternal life
By Bettina Arndt, Staff Writer
"Our darling Greg died of a broken heart," announced the death
notice placed by his mother and sister when federal MP Greg Wilton killed
himself last year.
Wilton's death attracted massive publicity, highlighting his marriage break-up
and loss of his children as events precipitating his drastic action. Three
weeks earlier, Wilton was found in a distressed state in a car with his two
Wilton, 44, was well aware of the vulnerability of men in his situation. Three
years earlier he gave a speech in parliament commenting on a report on youth
suicide, pointing out that the group at greatest risk of killing themselves
were adult men.
"From the extensive research (of) the last five years ... it becomes
apparent men kill themselves due to an inability to cope with life events such
as relationship break-ups of the kind (I) myself have suffered," said
Wilton, whose first marriage had ended in divorce.
Each year in Australia, more than 1000 men aged 25-44 take their own lives.
The rate of suicide among these adult males is more than twice the teenage
(15-19) suicide rate.
While the male teenage suicide rate has been stable for the past decade, the
rate for adult males has been rising since the 1970s. Most of them, like Greg
Wilton, are casualties of family breakdown.
A Queensland study of 4000 suicides found more than 70 per cent were
associated with a relationship break-up. The study, conducted by Professor
Pierre Baume, who is now at Monash University, showed men were nine times more
likely to take their lives following a break-up than women.
In the 1990s we spent more than $31 million on youth suicide prevention. Yet
no federal suicide funds have been targeted at the males showing the most
consistent rise in suicide rates. The plight of these men has only just made
it on to the national agenda.
This month our peak suicide prevention body - the National Advisory Council on
Suicide Prevention - for the first time is considering national initiatives
addressing this risk group. A series of meetings is being held between state
and federal suicide bodies, plus expert panels, to determine how to reach
Professor Ian Webster, chairman of the council, names this group as the
priority facing his committee. "It is a real problem for us. We are
trying to determine how best to approach it. I don't feel that as yet we have
any clear way of engaging with this risk group or deciding how to appeal to
Webster said his committee is likely to invite key research and interest
groups to propose new initiatives, an invitation welcomed by Chris Cantor, a
Queensland psychiatrist who has spent the past six years researching and
writing journal articles drawing attention to the unmet needs of this risk
group in suicide policies.
Cantor, who conducted some of his original research with Baume at Griffith
University's Australian Institute for Suicide Research and Prevention,
believes the link with relationship breakdown is critical.
His own research shows the risk of suicide is far higher for men in the period
following marital separation - the suicide risk among separated men was 18
times that of separated women - but, after divorce, the rates for men declined
to three times those of women.
Baume's data also points to the separation period as the critical risk time.
"The real risk is within four to six weeks of the separation rather than
after divorce. Men are most vulnerable immediately after rejection," he
Cantor questions whether the first weeks are so vital but feels this issue
needs exploring. He would like, through the Family Court, to track families
from the point of separation through to six months post-divorce, with regular
interviews of both parents and children to measure mental health, depression
and suicidal tendencies.
From his previous research, Cantor suspects that loss of meaningful contact
with children will emerge as a major risk factor for suicide. His research
shows women with children are less likely to commit suicide than similarly
aged women without children.
"It seems highly likely that most of the suicide problems associated with
separated men may relate to child access problems. The research suggests that
some non-custodial mothers may be in the same boat," he said.
Overseas, other researchers are reaching similar conclusions. Augustine
Kposowa, associate professor of sociology at the University of California at
Riverside, analysed data from the National Longitudinal Mortality Study and
found the ri sk ratio for divorced men is 8.6 times the rate for divorced
women. He, too, is convinced the key factor is men's loss of their children.
"Even with visitation rights, a man may not get to see his children. He's
already experienced loss of love through the break-up of the relationship and
then he faces the loss of his children. This drives some men, especially in
the early stages of separation, to come to the conclusion that life is not
worth living," said Kposowa, who is researching the role of the court
system and loss of custody in the heightened suicide risk for divorced men.
Edward Kruk, social work professor at the University of British Columbia in
Canada, has conducted research in both Britain and Canada on the impact of
divorce on fathers.
He found that, after losing daily contact with their offspring, the fathers
in his study passed through a grieving process similar to that of parents
whose child has died - 61 per cent described mental health difficulties
they had not experienced prior to the divorce, including suicidal tendencies.
Meanwhile, in Australia, an organization supporting separated men is gathering
data that demonstrates worrying suicidal tendencies in separated men. MENDS
(Men Exploring New Directional Strategies) programs have been running for more
than six years, recently with Commonwealth Government funding. Psychological
evaluations of more than 500 men attending the programs show most of them fall
into the highest risk category for "suicidality" - showing thinking
processes and behavior known to precede suicide.
MENDS has evidence its programs - based on education and the group support
provided by men sharing similar experiences - have a significant effect on
suicide risk during the critical separation period.
But the problem is how to reach separated men who are floundering on their
The founder of MENDS, psychologist Owen Pershouse, believes he has a possible
answer: "Between 30 and 40 per cent of calls we get following up
publicity about MENDS come from women. They are mostly mothers, sisters,
sometimes a work colleague or even the ex-wife. Women notice what's happening
to men they care about. They are the ones to target."
Baume agrees that women may provide the key to reaching these troubled men. He
believes the ultimate solution lies in long-term cultural change, teaching
boys that it is not unmanly to express their feelings so separated men don't
end up so isolated. But, given the reticence of the typical Australian male to
admit he's in trouble, Baume believes the answer lies in harnessing the power
of women to get men to talk to them.
Women like Alice. That's not her real name, but as the mother of a 23-year-old
who has just attempted suicide, Alice naturally wants to avoid publicity. Her
son is reeling from the loss of his two-year de facto relationship. The couple
has a three-month-old baby.
"This girl is his whole life. He feels life isn't worth living without
her and his new baby," said Alice, who luckily works in New South Wales
community services and was able to quickly obtain good psychiatric help for
her son. Her nervousness is increased by the fact that three years ago her son
attempted to hang himself when his first major relationship came to an end.
Listening to this mother talk about her son's dependency on these two young
women, one wonders how often broken relationships feature even in youth
suicides, when young men suffer the loss of that first taste of intimacy after
emotionally constrained years of male adolescence.
Clearly relationship breakdown isn't the whole story in the worrying increase
in male suicide - there are numerous other relevant factors, such as substance
abuse, mental illness, and unemployment. But given the evidence suggesting it
could be a key factor, at least it offers policy makers somewhere to start.
What Baume, Cantor and Pershouse are suggesting is public campaigns drawing
attention to the fact that recently separated men are high risk. If we can run
youth suicide prevention campaigns encouraging young men to look after their
mates, why can't we teach our community to watch out for men who have lost
Cantor, who suggests
workplace initiatives may be effective, believes these men may be an easier
target than youth, being more mature and aware of their responsibilities to
(please click above to vote for this
is Domestic Violence Against Men Awareness Month